State Legal Opinions Are Public Record By Cochran Douglas on September 12, 2007

In a unanimous opinion, the Supreme Court of Arkansas tossed out an earlier circuit court decision and ruled that legal opinions offered in letters by the state Department of Finance and Administration to taxpayers are public records subject to disclosure under the Arkansas Freedom of Information Act.

Chief Justice Jim Hannah, writing for the court, overruled the lower court’s decision that opinion letters written by the agency to taxpayers in response to specific tax questions were confidential and thus exempted from disclosure under the state’s public records law.

“[T]he legal opinions can be disclosed once confidential information is redacted of any information that identifies a taxpayer or other individual entity,” Hannah wrote.

In the underlying lawsuit, a tax consulting firm had requested certain letter opinions issued by the department, asking only for portions of the letters without any taxpayer identifying information.

The department denied the request, arguing that under the Arkansas Tax Procedure Act, agency opinions were protected from release entirely, much like individual tax returns or audits, because they were privileged taxpayer information.

The court disagreed, however, and distinguished tax information required to be filed with the agency from information generated by the agency.

“While the taxpayer information is certainly protected… the legal opinions in total are not protected under (the act),” Hannah wrote.

The court declined to address Ryan & Co.’s assertion that denial of the records was a constitutional violation.

https://www.rcfp.org/state-legal-opinions-are-public-record/

Logo

Cochran Douglas PERSONAL INJURY ATTORNEYS

Our personal injury attorneys have collected numerous honors and belong to noted professional organizations, ensuring they stay current with the ever-changing legal landscape. Among our honors and professional affiliations:

  • WSAJ: Washington State Association for Justice
  • WSBA: Washington State Bar Association
  • KCBA: King County Bar Association
  • TPCBA: Tacoma Pierce County Bar Association
  • Super Lawyers
  • Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum

Request a free consultation with our practice by contacting us online or by calling (253) 472-7777. We can meet at a location and time convenient for you, including nights and weekends.

 

Contact Us Today

Rate, Review & Explore

Social Accounts Sprite
Google map image of our location in 4826 Tacoma Mall Blvd Ste C Tacoma, WA

Tacoma Office

4826 Tacoma Mall Blvd
Ste C
Tacoma, WA 98409

Open Today 8:30am - 5:30pm

(253) 472-7777 Send a message